OTTAWA – Mark Carney’s first week as Prime Minister has already drawn sharp criticism. After the Liberals won a minority government on April 28, 2025, many expected Carney’s experience as an economist would set a new course for Canada.
Instead, his first days have been clouded by what critics call “eight broken promises and blunders.” This label has spread quickly on social media and in some news reports. Here’s a closer look at the claims and what they mean for Carney’s early days.
1. Familiar Faces in Cabinet
Carney promised a fresh start and a move away from Justin Trudeau’s approach. Yet, when the new cabinet was sworn in on May 14, 2025, it included many Trudeau-era ministers. Opposition Leader Pierre Poilievre pointed out that this doesn’t look like a change. Critics say Carney’s pledge for new ideas rings hollow, though his supporters believe experienced ministers are needed in uncertain times, especially with trade tensions rising.
2. Unclear Promises for the Arctic
Carney said he would bring bold change to the economy during his first press conference after the election. But when it comes to the Arctic, he didn’t offer clear plans. He spoke about fixing the cost of living, housing, and defence, but northern leaders felt left out. There were promises to work with Indigenous groups on northern projects, but no details. This has led to doubts about his real commitment to the North.
3. Access to Information: No Action
During the campaign, Carney said he’d review Canada’s access to information rules. But this promise didn’t appear in the official party platform. Critics like Duff Conacher from Democracy Watch say this shows a lack of real interest in government openness. Carney even admitted the idea was “in my head,” not as a formal plan. The vague promise is now seen as a misstep.
4. No Quick Moves on Trade Barriers
Carney campaigned on breaking down trade barriers between provinces by July 1, 2025, to boost Canada’s economy and counter U.S. tariffs. But in his first week, there was little sign of progress. Talks with provincial leaders have been pushed to a later date. Western provinces are growing restless, saying Carney’s promises aren’t matching up with action.
5. Big Economic Plans, No Clear Path
Carney’s speech on election night called for “the biggest transformation of Canada’s economy since World War II.” He mentioned $500 billion in new private investment. In his first week, however, there were no details on how this would happen. Business leaders want answers, and some analysts now question whether Carney’s background as a central banker is enough to guide Canada through these changes. The lack of a detailed plan has hurt his credibility.
See analysis from CBC and Financial Post. Read more in the Financial Post.
6. Confusion Over Energy Policy
Carney said he wanted Canada to be an “energy superpower” in both clean and traditional energy. But his move to scrap Trudeau’s carbon pricing program while keeping a tax on big emitters has left many confused. Alberta Premier Danielle Smith says Carney hasn’t changed much, and western provinces feel ignored. The lack of a clear approach is adding to regional frustration.
7. Defence Spending: No Progress Yet
Carney pledged to raise defence spending to NATO’s target of 2% of GDP by 2030, answering criticism from U.S. President Donald Trump. But no immediate steps have been taken, and the promised $30.9 billion increase is still on paper only. With new U.S. tariffs possible, some worry this slow pace could weaken Canada’s stance on security issues.
8. Slow Start on U.S. Trade Talks
A core promise in Carney’s campaign was to stand firm against Trump’s tariffs. But in his first week, the only step was to set up a meeting with the U.S. president on May 6. Reports say Trump is busy with other countries, putting talks with Canada on hold. Carney’s cautious approach hasn’t brought quick results, leaving some disappointed.
What’s Next for Carney?
The “eight broken promises and blunders” story is spreading online and in the news. While some of the criticism is fair, like vague ideas and missing plans, other issues reflect the reality of working with a minority government and complex problems.
Supporters say Carney’s steady style and experience in big economic roles will help him solve these problems over time. Critics worry his lack of political experience and past reputation for mixed signals could hurt public trust.
Carney now faces the challenge of turning words into real action, especially with the throne speech on May 27, 2025. With a minority government and growing regional tensions, he must act quickly to unite the country and make progress on his promises. The focus on his early missteps shows just how much pressure he faces to show results and rebuild confidence in Ottawa.
Related News:
Canada Stays on Sidelines as World Leaders Ink Historic Trade Deals Amid Trump Tariffs
